Audiobook Review: Love Letters for Other People by Shaylin Gandhi

Release date: December 9, 2025

Publisher: Harlequin Audio

Genre: Contemporary Romance

Narrator: Carly Robins

Synopsis:

An emotionally gripping page-turner about heartbreak, old secrets, and second chances—with an unexpected Cyrano twist. For fans of Lucy Score and Mia Sheridan.

When mathematician Aubrey MacLean’s career implodes, she has no choice but to return to her rural Indiana hometown, at least temporarily. But small towns have long memories, and so does she, especially when it comes to Nick Thacker, the boy who broke her heart.

Nick’s life is long shifts at the steel mill, plus a side business writing love letters for other people. It’s enough to numb his regrets—until his first love returns, stirring up a past he thought he’d buried.

Aubrey is focused on rebuilding her career, until she falls for a new man whose love letters feel achingly familiar. But as their connection deepens, so does her sense that she’s been here before. The similarities must be a coincidence, right? Because if not, Aubrey may have to choose between the life she’s built and the love she left behind…

Review:

Love Letters to Other People hit me right in the emotions, and the audio narration by Carly Robins made it feel even more intimate. She’s been one of my OG audiobook favorites since I first got into listening, so there’s a comfort and familiarity to her voice that instantly pulls me in. Her delivery captures the heartbreak, longing, and tentative hope between Aubrey and Nick in a way that feels raw and deeply human. From the very first chapter, I could feel the weight of their shared history and the ache of everything left unsaid.

Aubrey and Nick’s story unfolds across two timelines—past and present—which adds a beautiful emotional layering. You experience their high school romance as it blossoms and then fractures, and at the same time, you follow the adults they’ve become, still shaped by the choices they made 17 years earlier. That dual perspective makes their second chance arc feel earned, messy, and meaningful. The writing is romantic and heartfelt, and the inclusion of actual love letters added such a tender, nostalgic touch. Their journey to a hard won HEA is full of slow burn tension, emotional upheaval, and growth, and I loved every moment of watching them figure out who they are now, and who they want to be for each other.

If you love emotional second chance romances with secrets, history, and a whole lot of heart, this one absolutely delivers. It’s beautifully written and even more beautifully narrated, and listening to Carly Robins bring these characters to life made the experience feel personal and unforgettable.

Overall rating: 4/5

Thanks to the publisher for my review copy.

Ultimate Holiday Reading Guide 2025

Curl up with cocoa, turn on the twinkle lights, and settle in — your next festive read is right here.

Tip: the Instagram carousel features the full 100+ list with cover art, this blog shares a curated “highlight” selection plus blurbs and affiliate links.

💕 Holiday Romance Recs

Sweet, swoony, and full of festive cheer — these are the romances I’ve read and adored.

The Eight Heartbreaks of Hanukkah — A tender, heartwarming rom com centered on family, tradition, and second chances during Hanukkah.

Merry Christmas, You Filthy Animal — Irreverent, spicy, and unexpectedly emotional, perfect for readers who like their holiday romance with attitude.

Merry Little Kissmas — Sweet, cozy, and full of holiday mischief—ideal for fans of laugh out loud meet cutes.

Good Spirits — A warm, witty romance with a touch of magic and lots of seasonal charm.

The Christmas List — A nostalgic, cozy story about love, mistakes, and the miracle of second chances at Christmastime.

🎁 Holiday Romance TBR

If your e reader is ready for seasonal sparkle, these are next on my list.

Three Holidays and a Wedding — An emotional holiday romance about family, reunions, and one unforgettable festive celebration.

Snowed In — Classic snowbound trope with sparks, secrets, and the perfect forced proximity setup.

Christmas Fling — A flirty holiday romance made for cozy winter nights.

How the Grump Saved Christmas — Grumpy x sunshine holiday energy with tender moments and lots of heart.

Christmas Eve Love Story — A sweet, cinematic romance that feels like your favorite holiday movie in book form.

🔪 Holiday Thriller TBR

Prefer your holiday reads on the darker side? These chilling thrillers bring murder, mystery, and a touch of tinsel.

I’ll Be Alone for Christmas — A tense, psychological holiday thriller about isolation and the danger of being alone on Christmas.

The Christmas Party — An old friends reunion that goes terrifyingly wrong—perfect for readers who love locked room tension at Christmas.

The Christmas Killer — Chilling, relentless, and set against a deceptively cozy holiday backdrop.

Last Christmas — A twisty festive thriller that will keep you guessing until the final pages.

The Christmas Guest — A short, sinister holiday novella where seasonal cheer turns cold and dangerous.

☕ Cozy Mystery Recs

For those who love crime with cocoa and clues with candy canes — these festive whodunits are perfect fireside reading.

Murder at the Christmas Cookie Bake-Off — Baking mishaps, small town charm, and a deliciously twisty mystery.

Mistletoe Murder — Classic cozy energy: holiday traditions, nosy neighbors, and a puzzling murder to solve.

Rest Ye Murdered Gentlemen — A festive small town mystery with holiday events and plenty of red herrings.

Murder with a Hint of Peppermint — A sweet sleuthing romp with peppermint lattes and cozy clues.

The Diva Cooks a Goose — Light, funny, and full of culinary chaos—mystery meets kitchen hijinks.

🔍 Cozy Mystery TBR

Still can’t get enough? These upcoming holiday cozies are next in my queue.

The Most Wonderful Crime of the Year — A festive, puzzle filled cozy that reads like a gingerbread house of clues.

A Holiday Homicide — Small town drama and a seasonal whodunit that’s perfect with a cup of cocoa.

Peppermint Cookie Murder — A charming bakery mystery that pairs perfectly with cookie baking and sleuthing.

Death of a Christmas Caterer — Catering drama, family secrets, and a holiday themed mystery that’s delightfully suspicious.

Deck the Hallways — Festive campus hijinks and a cozy mystery vibe that’s quirky and fun.

That’s 25 festive reads to get you through the season — and my full 100+ books Holiday Reading Guide (with every genre + cover art) is on Instagram if you want every single recommendation.

Follow @novelgossip on Instagram for the complete carousel and more holiday reading inspo.

Affiliate disclosure: I use Amazon affiliate links on this page. If you purchase through these links I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — thank you for supporting novelgossip.com.

Review: Home Sweet Holiday Collection

Release date: November 20, 2025

Publisher: Amazon Originals

Genre: Romance

Synopsis:

Snow Place Like Home

After a devastating breakup, a sunny veterinarian goes home to the mountains to lick her wounds—and savor a holiday snack—in this heartfelt story from Laura Pavlov, author of the Blushing series.

At her brother’s wedding, Goldie Jacobs brushes shoulders with Ace Bonetti, his childhood best friend turned Hollywood hotshot. Ace has been crushing on Goldie ever since high school, and seeing her again reminds him exactly why. They spend one toe-curling night together, then part ways, expecting nothing more. But when those moments under the mistletoe felt so right, how can they ever let each other go?

Laura Pavlov’s Snow Place Like Home is part of Home Sweet Holidays, a cookie-sweet collection of holiday romances sure to bring color to your cheeks. Read or listen to each story in a single heart-fluttering sitting. And to fully immerse yourself in the charm of the season, don’t miss a special message from each of our holiday heroes!

Goodreads

Merry and Bright

What starts as a Hail Mary fake romance scheme turns into the real deal in this delightful story of holiday deception from Ali Rosen, author of Alternate Endingsand Recipe for Second Chances.

Miriam Brody is dreading Hanukkah with her overbearing family in Charleston. Ditto for dreamy pro football player Cal Durand and Christmas. After sharing a few flirty drinks on the flight there, the strangers conspire to tackle the holidays together, posing as a couple. But as shenanigans unfold, Miriam realizes her feelings are anything but fake. Uh-oh. Are they headed for a holiday miracle—or a holiday disaster?

Ali Rosen’s Merry and Bright is part of Home Sweet Holidays, a cookie-sweet collection of holiday romances sure to bring color to your cheeks. Read or listen to each story in a single heart-fluttering sitting. And to fully immerse yourself in the charm of the season, don’t miss a special message from each of our holiday heroes!

Goodreads

Review:

The Home Sweet Holiday Collection is a delightful bite sized holiday treat, perfect for cozying up with a cup of cocoa. Of the four stories, two really stood out for me, delivering charm, festive vibes, and swoon worthy romance.

Snow Place Like Home by Laura Pavlov follows Goldie, a veterinarian, as she returns home for her brother’s Christmas Day wedding, and Ace, her brother’s best friend and a movie star, who has secretly harbored feelings for her for years. The story is fast, sweet, and full of the author’s signature wit, capturing that perfect mix of holiday cheer, romantic tension, and heartfelt confessions. The wedding set during Christmas adds an extra layer of festive fun, and watching these longtime crushes finally admit their feelings was incredibly satisfying.

Merry and Bright by Ali Rosen was my first by this author, but it certainly won’t be my last. The story follows Miriam and Cal, who meet on a flight home for the holidays—she’s celebrating Hanukkah, he Christmas—and immediately click. Both dreading the family festivities, they agree to a fake dating arrangement that feels effortless and believable. The chemistry between them is instant, sweet, and festive, making this story a standout for its humor, warmth, and that perfect holiday sparkle.

Overall, these two stories made the collection worth diving into, each offering a unique slice of holiday romance that’s fun, heartwarming, and utterly bingeable in one sitting.

Overall rating: 4/5

Thanks to the publisher for my review copy.

Review: Where He Left Me by Nicole Baart

Goodreads

Release date: November 4, 2025

Publisher: Atria

Genre: Mystery/Thriller

Synopsis:

College professors Sadie Sheridan and Felix Graham are on sabbatical at Hemlock House, located on a remote mountain homestead established years ago by Felix’s family. When Felix leaves on a work trip but doesn’t return, effectively stranding Sadie on the mountain, her world collapses.

Alone at Hemlock House, frantic Sadie struggles to make sense of what her missing astronomer husband left behind. Forced to confront two mysterious trespassers just as a powerful storm bears down, Sadie and the strangers have no choice but to ride it out together. As conditions worsen and shocking secrets are revealed, Sadie must face whether or not she ever knew the man she married and is she fighting only for her own survival now—or still for the man who promised her the stars?

Where He Left Me is another compelling, emotional thriller from an author who “writes with a poet’s eye for language and a storyteller’s gift for suspense” (William Kent Krueger, New York Times bestselling author).

Review:

Nicole Baart delivers another deeply emotional and quietly haunting story in Where He Left Me. The novel follows Sadie, who retreats with her husband, Felix, to his family’s vacation home Hemlock House, a sprawling estate with an unsettling presence. When Felix leaves for a business trip and doesn’t return on time, Sadie finds herself alone in the house as a storm closes in. Her solitude is soon broken by the arrival of two strangers trespassing on the property, and what unfolds from there is a taut, layered exploration of grief, betrayal, and the secrets we keep.

Told through alternating timelines that trace Sadie and Felix’s relationship from its earliest moments to the tense present, Baart crafts a slow burn suspense that feels both intimate and cinematic. The shifting narrative builds a steady undercurrent of dread, while her lyrical writing grounds the story in emotional realism. As the storm outside grows more violent, the true turbulence lies within Hemlock House—and within Sadie herself—as the truth begins to surface in unexpected and unsettling ways.

Where He Left Me is atmospheric, beautifully written, and psychologically rich. Baart’s signature blend of emotional depth and understated suspense shines here, making this one of those quiet thrillers that lingers long after the final page. If you enjoy character driven mysteries that balance tension with introspection, this is a must read.

Overall rating: 4/5

Thanks to the publisher for my review copy.