Death by Eggnog by Alex Erickson

A festive cozy mystery audiobook review of Death by Eggnog by Alex Erickson, book five in the Bookstore Café Mystery series, narrated by Melissa Moran.

Goodreads | Death by Eggnog

Release date: September 26, 2027

Publisher: Kensington

Genre: Cozy Mystery

Synopsis:

Krissy Hancock is staying in her adopted hometown of Pine Hills, Ohio, for Christmas this year–and she even has a whole week off from her combination bookstore-cafe. But a killer is about to dampen her spirits . . .

Unfortunately, Krissy’s been roped into filling in for a sick elf in the local holiday musical extravaganza. With a demanding director, backstage gossip, and two men in fierce competition for the starring role, it isn’t all sweetness and Christmas lights. Then a murder puts a stop to the production, and Krissy is faced with a pageant of suspects.

Could her ex-boyfriend, a fellow elf, really be the culprit as the police are claiming? Or will the actor playing Santa be trading his red suit for an orange jumpsuit? When her behind-the-scenes investigation starts getting dangerous, the only thing Krissy really wants is to make it to Christmas dinner alive. But first she’ll have to finish wrapping up this case . . .

Review:

I’m officially settling into the Bookstore Café Mystery series, and I’m so glad I stuck with it! After a somewhat rocky start with the first couple of books, each installment has felt a little stronger, and I’m finding myself more invested in the characters and the town of Pine Hills. And perhaps most importantly, Krissy manages to annoy me a little less with every book. 😂 Progress!

This time around, Krissy is hoping for a relaxing Christmas in Pine Hills, but naturally, murder has other plans. After getting roped into participating in a local holiday production, she finds herself surrounded by backstage drama, plenty of suspicious characters, and eventually a murder investigation. So much for a peaceful holiday season!

I actually think this might be the strongest mystery in the series so far. There were plenty of red herrings, a solid lineup of suspects, and enough twists and misdirection to keep me guessing. I really enjoyed the mystery itself, and it’s nice to see the series becoming more consistent in that department. I’m also getting more comfortable with the recurring characters and the dynamics of this little community, which makes each visit to Pine Hills more enjoyable.

I’m getting the feeling we might be veering back into love triangle territory, or at least that’s the vibe I’m picking up on, and I’m curious to see where that goes. As for the Christmas setting, I thought the balance was just right. There was plenty of festive atmosphere and holiday cheer without it becoming overwhelming or taking attention away from the mystery. It felt like a genuine Christmas cozy while still delivering a satisfying whodunit.

I listened to the audiobook narrated by Melissa Moran, who continues to be such an engaging and delightful narrator. Her voice is pleasant and easy to listen to, and she brings a lovely warmth to the story. She’s become a familiar part of my experience with this series, and her narration is a great fit for the cozy atmosphere.

Overall, Death by Eggnog was another enjoyable installment, and I’m really liking the direction this series is heading. The mysteries are getting stronger, the characters are growing on me, and Pine Hills is starting to feel like a familiar place to revisit. This one delivered a great combination of Christmas cheer and murder, and I’m definitely looking forward to continuing the series!

Perfect for Readers Who Love

🎄 Christmas cozies with just the right amount of holiday cheer

🔎 Twisty small town mysteries packed with suspects and red herrings

🎭 Holiday productions, backstage drama, and murderous secrets

☕ Bookstore cafés, familiar characters, and charming communities

🎧 Warm, engaging audiobook narration that’s easy to settle into

💕 A little romantic drama mixed into the mystery

Overall rating: 4/5

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, I may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. Thank you for supporting Novelgossip! 

Leave a Reply