Thanksgiving Cozy Mysteries

10 Cozy Mysteries Filled With Turkey, Pie, Family Drama & Murder

Thanksgiving already has all the ingredients of a cozy mystery: a house full of people, family drama, too many opinions, an alarming number of kitchen knives and at least one person who’s been holding a grudge since 1997. 😂 Add a dead body and honestly, we’re halfway there.

Thanksgiving mysteries are a surprisingly fun little corner of the cozy genre. These ten books take us from traditional holiday dinners and baking competitions to Turkey Trots, small town celebrations and even Thanksgiving with Mrs. Claus. Because apparently murder does not take federal holidays off.

I’ve read some of these authors and series already, while others are firmly on my own cozy TBR, so think of this as a seasonal discovery list rather than ten personal reviews. If you want something festive to read while avoiding your own family’s Thanksgiving drama, here’s your menu.

Want All the Thanksgiving Cozies in One Place? 🦃

I’ve gathered all 10 books together on so you can browse the entire list in one spot.

→ Browse Thanksgiving Cozy Mysteries

The Diva Runs Out of Thyme by Krista Davis

Sophie Winston is preparing for Thanksgiving—and a holiday cooking competition—when murder turns the festivities into something much more complicated.

Even better, this is the first Domestic Diva Mystery, which makes it an unusually easy holiday cozy to jump into without worrying about starting halfway through an established series.

Thanksgiving vibes: Cooking competition, holiday food & family

Start here if: You want Thanksgiving to introduce you to an entire cozy series.

A Catered Thanksgiving by Isis Crawford

The Simmons sisters are catering a Thanksgiving dinner when the holiday takes a decidedly murderous turn.

A catering centered mystery feels especially appropriate for Thanksgiving, when approximately 94 percent of everyone’s attention is already focused on food. 😂

Thanksgiving vibes: Catering, holiday dinner & plenty of food

Start here if: Culinary cozies are your comfort zone.

Thankfully Dead by Kathleen Suzette

Part of the Freshly Baked Mysteries, this one combines the series’ home baking coziness with Thanksgiving and murder—basically an ideal November reading combination.

Thanksgiving vibes: Home baking, holiday atmosphere & murder

Start here if: You like short, fast, easy cozy reads.

Death of a Tom Turkey by Lee Hollis

When your cozy mystery is literally called Death of a Tom Turkey, I feel reasonably confident we’ve met the Thanksgiving assignment. 😂

Part of the long running Hayley Powell Food & Cocktails Mysteries, this gives readers a food forward mystery from an established cozy series with a very obvious seasonal hook.

Thanksgiving vibes: Turkey, food & holiday homicide

Start here if: You like culinary mysteries with humor.

Thanksgiving Turkey Tragedy by Leighann Dobbs

Thanksgiving preparations in the Lexy Baker Mysteries become significantly more complicated when murder joins the holiday festivities.

Between the Thanksgiving feast, turkeys and Lexy’s culinary world, this is about as unapologetically seasonal as a November cozy can get.

Thanksgiving vibes: Turkeys, town festivities & baked goods

Start here if: You want maximum Thanksgiving energy.

Peanut Butter Panic by Amanda Flower

Harvest, Ohio is preparing for a huge community Thanksgiving celebration, and Bailey King and Swissmen Sweets are responsible for supplying desserts. Naturally, murder complicates the menu.

The Amish Candy Shop Mysteries bring a completely different atmosphere to this list, with Amish country charm, candy making and a village wide Thanksgiving celebration.

Thanksgiving vibes: Community feast, candy shop & Amish country

Start here if: You want a cozy community setting with lots of food.

In the Blink of a Pie by Catherine Bruns

Vermont, maple syrup, Thanksgiving and pie? You barely need to tell me there’s a murder. I’m already interested. 😂

Part of the Maple Syrup Mysteries, this one gives us that quintessential late-fall New England atmosphere along with the food and family elements that make Thanksgiving such a natural setting for cozy mysteries.

Thanksgiving vibes: Vermont, maple syrup & pie

Start here if: Atmosphere matters almost as much as the mystery.

Trapping, Turkeys, & Thanksgiving by Tonya Kappes

Thanksgiving arrives in Kentucky complete with a Turkey Trot, Southern food, returning family members and—because this is a cozy mystery—murder.

The Camper & Criminals Mysteries give us a campground setting instead of another kitchen or bakery, which adds some fun variety while keeping all the holiday atmosphere.

Thanksgiving vibes: Turkey Trot, campground & Southern Thanksgiving

Start here if: You like quirky small towns and outdoor settings.

Turkey Day Murder by Leslie Meier

Lucy Stone’s Thanksgiving in Tinker’s Cove comes complete with holiday traditions, family life and a murder that needs solving.

The Lucy Stone Mysteries are one of those classic long running cozy series, and this older installment is proof that cozy authors have been ruining fictional Thanksgiving dinners for decades. 😂

Thanksgiving vibes: Traditional Thanksgiving, New England & family

Start here if: You love classic old school cozies.

Mrs. Claus and the Trouble with Turkeys by Liz Ireland

And then there’s this glorious little weirdo. 😂

The Mrs. Claus Mysteries bring Thanksgiving to the world of Santaland, giving us turkeys, murder and just enough Christmas-adjacent absurdity to remind us what’s waiting immediately on the other side of November.

Thanksgiving vibes: Thanksgiving meets the North Pole

Start here if: You want the most unusual holiday cozy on the list.

Apparently Thanksgiving Needed More Drama

Honestly, Thanksgiving might be one of the most logical holidays for a cozy mystery.

You’ve gathered a large group of relatives and acquaintances in one place. Everyone has history. Someone is stressed about dinner. Someone else is drinking. There are sharp objects everywhere.

What could possibly go wrong? 😂

These ten give us everything from traditional family dinners and cooking competitions to community celebrations, Turkey Trots and Thanksgiving in Santaland. So whether you’re spending the holiday surrounded by relatives or blissfully hiding from everyone with a book, there’s a murder here for you.

Perfect for Readers Who Love:

  • Thanksgiving books
  • Holiday cozy mysteries
  • Culinary mysteries
  • Small town settings
  • Family gatherings and drama
  • Seasonal food and baking
  • Amateur sleuths
  • Festive mysteries without anything scary

Pass the Pie—and the Murder 🥧🔎

If your ideal November reading includes turkey, pie, crisp fall atmosphere and one extremely inconvenient dead body, these Thanksgiving cozies belong on your TBR.

→ Find Thanksgiving Cozy Mysteries Here

Leave a Reply