Review: Everyone is Perfect Here by Jane Haseldine

Goodreads

Release date: April 7, 2026

Publisher: Severn House

Genre: Mystery/Thriller

Synopsis:

A woman’s life is upended when her past comes back to mess with her mind in this psychological thriller full of twists and turns.

There’s no such thing as perfect.

It’s been fifteen years since Carly Bennett’s mother was brutally murdered during a home robbery. Since then, she’s worked hard to build a normal life with a stellar career as an English professor—far away from the picture-perfect stepfamily that abandoned her at boarding school.

When a male colleague is found dead in Carly’s office—her name scrawled next to his body—everything she’s strived for starts to fall apart. There are eerie similarities to her mother’s attack, and Carly determines to find the truth. 

Yet things take a bizarre turn when she suddenly experiences lost time, waking up in strange places, and flashes of dormant memories . . . memories that can’t possibly be real. Because, if they are, then she was there the night her mother was killed.

Could Carly have been responsible? Or is something more sinister at play in her stepfamily’s perfect world . . .?

This eerie domestic suspense is perfect for fans of Frieda McFadden and Lisa Jewell.

Review:

Everyone Is Perfect Here by Jane Haseldine is an engaging, twisty domestic suspense that leans heavily into family drama, buried trauma, and the lingering impact of the past. Told across dual timelines, the story follows Carly Bennett as she’s pulled back into the mystery of her mother’s murder, an event that shattered her childhood and continues to echo into her present. The past and present structure keeps the narrative moving at a steady, compelling pace, gradually revealing secrets that reshape everything Carly thought she knew.

Carly herself is an intriguing and layered protagonist, especially as her grip on reality begins to blur with unsettling memory gaps and flashes of something darker beneath the surface. The story thrives on that eerie uncertainty—what really happened, what can be trusted, and how much of the past has been buried for a reason. The pacing is quick and the twists keep things entertaining, making it an easy book to fly through, especially for fans of family centered thrillers with psychological elements.

While this one didn’t fully land as a standout for me, it was still a solid and enjoyable read. The exploration of trauma and complicated family dynamics adds depth, even as the story leans into more dramatic, twist driven moments. Overall, it’s a fast paced, intriguing suspense that will appeal to readers who enjoy unraveling messy family secrets with a touch of unreliability and tension.

Overall rating: 3.5/5

Thanks to the publisher for my review copy.

Ultimate Holiday Reading Guide 2025

Curl up with cocoa, turn on the twinkle lights, and settle in — your next festive read is right here.

Tip: the Instagram carousel features the full 100+ list with cover art, this blog shares a curated “highlight” selection plus blurbs and affiliate links.

💕 Holiday Romance Recs

Sweet, swoony, and full of festive cheer — these are the romances I’ve read and adored.

The Eight Heartbreaks of Hanukkah — A tender, heartwarming rom com centered on family, tradition, and second chances during Hanukkah.

Merry Christmas, You Filthy Animal — Irreverent, spicy, and unexpectedly emotional, perfect for readers who like their holiday romance with attitude.

Merry Little Kissmas — Sweet, cozy, and full of holiday mischief—ideal for fans of laugh out loud meet cutes.

Good Spirits — A warm, witty romance with a touch of magic and lots of seasonal charm.

The Christmas List — A nostalgic, cozy story about love, mistakes, and the miracle of second chances at Christmastime.

🎁 Holiday Romance TBR

If your e reader is ready for seasonal sparkle, these are next on my list.

Three Holidays and a Wedding — An emotional holiday romance about family, reunions, and one unforgettable festive celebration.

Snowed In — Classic snowbound trope with sparks, secrets, and the perfect forced proximity setup.

Christmas Fling — A flirty holiday romance made for cozy winter nights.

How the Grump Saved Christmas — Grumpy x sunshine holiday energy with tender moments and lots of heart.

Christmas Eve Love Story — A sweet, cinematic romance that feels like your favorite holiday movie in book form.

🔪 Holiday Thriller TBR

Prefer your holiday reads on the darker side? These chilling thrillers bring murder, mystery, and a touch of tinsel.

I’ll Be Alone for Christmas — A tense, psychological holiday thriller about isolation and the danger of being alone on Christmas.

The Christmas Party — An old friends reunion that goes terrifyingly wrong—perfect for readers who love locked room tension at Christmas.

The Christmas Killer — Chilling, relentless, and set against a deceptively cozy holiday backdrop.

Last Christmas — A twisty festive thriller that will keep you guessing until the final pages.

The Christmas Guest — A short, sinister holiday novella where seasonal cheer turns cold and dangerous.

☕ Cozy Mystery Recs

For those who love crime with cocoa and clues with candy canes — these festive whodunits are perfect fireside reading.

Murder at the Christmas Cookie Bake-Off — Baking mishaps, small town charm, and a deliciously twisty mystery.

Mistletoe Murder — Classic cozy energy: holiday traditions, nosy neighbors, and a puzzling murder to solve.

Rest Ye Murdered Gentlemen — A festive small town mystery with holiday events and plenty of red herrings.

Murder with a Hint of Peppermint — A sweet sleuthing romp with peppermint lattes and cozy clues.

The Diva Cooks a Goose — Light, funny, and full of culinary chaos—mystery meets kitchen hijinks.

🔍 Cozy Mystery TBR

Still can’t get enough? These upcoming holiday cozies are next in my queue.

The Most Wonderful Crime of the Year — A festive, puzzle filled cozy that reads like a gingerbread house of clues.

A Holiday Homicide — Small town drama and a seasonal whodunit that’s perfect with a cup of cocoa.

Peppermint Cookie Murder — A charming bakery mystery that pairs perfectly with cookie baking and sleuthing.

Death of a Christmas Caterer — Catering drama, family secrets, and a holiday themed mystery that’s delightfully suspicious.

Deck the Hallways — Festive campus hijinks and a cozy mystery vibe that’s quirky and fun.

That’s 25 festive reads to get you through the season — and my full 100+ books Holiday Reading Guide (with every genre + cover art) is on Instagram if you want every single recommendation.

Follow @novelgossip on Instagram for the complete carousel and more holiday reading inspo.

Affiliate disclosure: I use Amazon affiliate links on this page. If you purchase through these links I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — thank you for supporting novelgossip.com.